Sell & Trade LEGO – Get the Best Value for Your Collection

BY APPOINTMENTS ONLY.

Why Trade Your LEGO with Florida Man’s Toys?

At Florida Man’s Toys, we are proud to be Florida’s highest and best-rated LEGO resale store! As a small mom-and-pop shop, we are passionate about all things LEGO, offering one of the largest selections of new and pre-owned LEGO sets and minifigures anywhere in the state.

Unlike other LEGO resellers, we’re the only store in Florida that offers full cash value for LEGO sets and minifigures. This has made us the #1 choice for LEGO sellers and collectors, bringing in a significant number of trade-in requests every day. To keep things fair and efficient, we’ve developed a structured trade-in policy that ensures we can provide the best service to everyone.

How Our LEGO Trade-In Process Works

Step 1: Fill Out Our Online Trade-In Form

To ensure a smooth process, we require all trade-ins to start with our online form. This helps us assess your items and schedule an appointment so we can give you the best possible offer.

  • Complete the Online Trade-In Form (link to form).
  • Tell us about your LEGO sets, minifigures, or bulk bricks.
  • We’ll review your submission and schedule an appointment.

Step 2: Trade-In Appointment & Appraisal

Once your appointment is confirmed, bring your LEGO items to our store. Our expert team will assess them based on:
Condition (New, used, complete, or incomplete sets)
Demand & Market Value (We use platforms like BrickLink and eBay)
Rarity & Popularity (Some themes may receive higher offers)

Step 3: Choose Your Payment Option

We offer multiple ways to get value from your LEGO trade-in:

  • Cash Offer: 50% of the fair market value.
  • Store Credit: 60% of the fair market value.
  • Cash + Store Credit Combo: A mix of both for added value.

Walk-In Trade-Ins: Store Credit Only

To ensure fairness and efficiency, we only offer store credit for walk-in trade-ins without a scheduled appointment. If you want a cash option, please fill out our online form and schedule an appointment first.


Florida Man’s Toys LEGO Trade-In Policy

To maintain fair and transparent trade-ins, we follow these guidelines:

1. What We Accept for Trade-Ins

New & Used LEGO Sets – Complete or incomplete.
LEGO Minifigures – Individual or bulk collections.
Bulk LEGO Bricks – Clean and sorted pieces are preferred.
Retired & Rare Sets – High-demand sets may receive higher offers.

2. What We Do NOT Accept

Non-LEGO Branded Items – No knock-off brands.
NO Smoke Scented LEGO – NO Smoke Scented LEGO
Broken or Severely Damaged Pieces – Dirty, discolored, or incomplete beyond repair.
Custom Painted or Modified LEGO – Only official LEGO products are accepted.

3. Store Credit Usage Policy

To prevent excessive credit-for-credit exchanges, store credit can be used for up to 50% of a purchase. The remaining balance must be paid in cash, card, or another accepted payment method.

💡 Example: If you’re purchasing a $100 LEGO set, you can apply up to $50 in store credit, and the rest must be paid in cash or card.

4. High-Volume Trade-Ins

For large collections (15+ sets or bulk bins over 20 lbs), we require an appointment to ensure we have time to assess your items fairly.

5. Expiration & Non-Transferability

  • Store credit does not expire but is non-transferable (must be used by the original recipient).
  • We do not buy back store credit once issued.

Ready to Trade Your LEGO? Start Here!

If you have LEGO sets, minifigures, or bulk bricks you’d like to trade, get started today:

📌 Step 1: Fill out the Trade-In Form
📌 Step 2: Schedule an appointment
📌 Step 3: Get paid in cash or store credit!

Got Questions? Visit us in-store or contact us at 📧 [your email] | 📞 [your phone number].


Why Choose Florida Man’s Toys for LEGO Trade-Ins?

Highest Rated LEGO Reseller in Florida – Hundreds of 5-star reviews.
Fair & Transparent Trade-In Values – Based on real market demand.
Cash Offers Available – Unlike competitors who only offer store credit.
Huge Selection of LEGO – Trade in your old sets for something new!

Whether you’re looking to sell your LEGO collection, upgrade to rare sets, or get store credit for your next build, Florida Man’s Toys is the best place to trade LEGO in Florida!